a unique experience that begs to be repeated

PepperoniRolls

Our wedding cake shop has expanded to a storefront featuring a wide variety of our favorite recipes and specialty desserts, all available by the serving. Come indulge in our full-service espresso bar, loose leaf teas, fruit smoothies, and sparkling Italian sodas.

ButlerEagleGold2015MedReader’s Choice Best Bakery, Best Dessert, Best Cookies, Best Cake

Located at 800 W New Castle Street in Butler, three blocks up the hill from the old Stanley’s Bakery. Parking lot entrance on N 6th Ave.

Featured this week

Beginning Monday, April 4th, Butler Health System will begin offering Pennie’s baked goods in three locations!

Beginning Monday, April 4th, Butler Health System will begin offering Pennie’s baked goods in three locations!  We are beyond excited to begin this relationship with a World-Class Healthcare Provider like Butler Health System! ‪#‎ButlerProud‬

Our products will be available inside the Main Cafeteria and the To Your Health Cafe (located inside the Brady Street Entrance) at the Butler Memorial Hospital. You will also find our goodies inside the Cafe located at the Crossroads Campus, located off Route 422 and Rt 68 in Butler!

Please share this exciting news with your friends, family, and work associates!

For a chance to WIN 1 DOZEN FILLED CUPCAKES, share this post and or tag friends (Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram) that live near or work at one of these locations. We will post the winner this Monday!

dc6d519c-d68a-4ba6-a5e3-a1a9efc00ff8

OUR MISSION IS SIMPLE

HAPPY GUESTS

Our goal is to give everyone a taste of our passion through the many special desserts we offer and personal attention we give. We don’t consider ourselves a business in the normal sense of the word, we consider ourselves a family, and we’d like our guests to feel the same way. When we see that small smile of delight appear on a person’s face after sampling a pastry, or look of awe after trying a Pennie Cake for the first time, we’ve accomplished our goal.

FREE WIFI IN OUR INDOOR
AND OUTDOOR SEATING AREAS

BEAUTIFUL

WEDDING CAKES

SPECIALTY

DESSERTS

FILLED & DECORATED

CUPCAKES

COFFEES, TEAS &

OTHER FARE